For Emma, Forever Ago
A lone cabin. A lonely man. These
are the two major flames that sparked Bon Iver’s debut album, For Emma, Forever Ago. After suffering
from both a romantic breakup and a breakup from his previous band, DeYarmond
Edison, Justin Vernon, singer-songwriter and front man of Bon Iver, picked up
his things and retreated to his father’s isolated cabin in the woods amidst a
wintery Wisconsin. In just three months of serenity and seclusion, Vernon wrote
the lyrics and created the bulk of the music of For Emma, Forever Ago, the album that formed the roots for his new
band, Bon Iver. The artist used minimal music equipment, only a few guitars as
the main instrumentation, plus a microphone and a laptop to layer his vocals
and make his voice imitate a large choir in a majority of the songs. After
emerging from the cabin and returning to his home in Raleigh, North Carolina, Vernon
next asked some of his friends to add instruments to the tracks, such as the trumpet
and trombone. These musician friends later became the other members of Bon
Iver. Then, without the help of any professional recording companies, Vernon
self-released the album as the sole producer. The cliché “Less is More” could
easily be used to classify For Emma,
Forever Ago because the album can come off as simplistic at first glance.
With a closer look however, one will find how the music is just the tip of the
iceberg of Vernon’s message and there is a lot of meaning to be discovered
under the surface.
The conditions under which Justin
Vernon worked on this album eerily parallel the 1845 artistic experiment of
American Romantic author, Henry David Thoreau, who moved to a small, serene Massachusetts
home next to Walden Pond for two years and two months. The result of this
experience was the creation of his book, Walden,
about the benefits of “retir[ing] to a lonely spot” in nature “--even if only
in imagination--to ponder the world and [your] place in it (Witherell). In
regards to his decision to isolate himself, Thoreau said, “I went to the woods
because I wished to live deliberately, to front only the essential facts of
life, and see if I could not learn what it had to teach, and not, when I came
to die, discover that I had not lived” (Thoreau 90).
By connecting with nature, many Romantics
during Thoreau’s time period found their once objective reality of the world
could disappear, permitting a renewed awareness of, or relationship to,
society. These artists credit their ability to overcome a disconnect between
“the self and the world” with their appreciation of nature and their ability to
submerge in the essence of nature. (Riasanovsky 71). In the same way,
Justin Vernon’s preoccupation with nature and decision to remove himself from
society to create For Emma, Forever Ago could
demonstrate his attempt to solve a disconnect he feels with society as well as
his attempt to figure out his identity after experiencing failed love with both
his band and girlfriend. With this album, Vernon is reviving fundamental ideas
of Romanticism because “unable to find happiness in the world of man,” the Romanticist
often took the time to reflect in only the presence of nature, which served as “an
escape from man and reality” (Kravitt 99, 100). In an interview with the A.V. Club, Bon Iver’s singer-songwriter described
his seclusion from the world as a form of meditation and reflection saying, “I
don't think I really had any clue what was going on while I was there. I was
just there” (Vernon).
In the opening song of the album,
Justin Vernon’s submersion into the secluded landscape of Wisconsin is immediately
revealed as he paints a picture both lyrically and musically of a calming
river. There is an even tempo of the guitar that remains consistent throughout
the track, imitating the balanced, continual rhythm of flowing water. The title
of this introductory song alone, “Flume,” signifies a deep, narrow stream of
water, but specific lines like “I move in water shore, to shore” and “Lapping
lakes like leery loons” also add to the imagery. Not only does the artist
merely notice or observe these snapshots of nature that surrounds him however, Vernon
also sings of a familiar connection between humans and nature with the repeated
line, “Sky is womb and she’s the moon.”
In another track, “For Emma,” the
human relationship with nature is reified as the concept of being able to find
comfort or refuge in nature or the physical world emerges in the repetition of
the line, “Running home.” Like Vernon, Romantics recognized nature as a valuable element of our world that can be a source of inspiration for
finding purpose in life (Riasanovsky 70). In this track Bon Iver also reveals
evidence of how nature's beauty is an outlet that can break our close-minded,
rigid perception of life to open our eyes to a new understanding of both
ourselves and the world. In “For Emma,” the artist recognizes the emotional
effect that the beauty of nature has on people. He gives a contrasting positive and negative
view as he sings, “Saw death on a sunny snow.” Winter is the season that can
achieve such a massive emotional response from people because of its gray,
cold, dark, barren, dead, and dangerous qualities. Research has even proven
that moods of depression, hostility, anxiety, anger and irritability are
stronger in the winter months than any other time of the year (Harmatz 349).
The singer himself experienced some of these negative feelings as a
result of being stuck in what seems like a Winter Wonderland prison for three
months. Yet by placing himself in this environment voluntarily, Vernon also witnessed
a positive effect of this season by being able to discover himself and
reposition his head back on his shoulders through meditating in nature.
The references to winter reoccur
in the rest of the album, working to symbolize the way the artist was viewing
the world and society at the time of creating the music. In an interview with
Angela Kim of Weekend America, Vernon
states that, “Just winter in general was kind of a part of where I was
physically and metaphysically as well” “because about February every year is
when it gets really hard;” “it's when people's hearts really start to give out”
(“Songs in the Dead of Winter”). In “re: Stacks” Justin Vernon sings, “All my
love was down in a frozen ground.” These lyrics demonstrate how our surroundings
influence us as humans, and can imply that the weight of winter makes the
artist want to quit searching for meaning in relationships and give up on
seeking love and happiness in life. In the reverse however, this line of lyrics
can also reflect how Vernon’s state of becoming out-of-touch with love has made
life seem hopeless or worthless. Thus this perspective creates a cold, bleak,
and unfulfilling outlook of the world for the artist in the same way people often
view life during the winter. The winter motif could show how Vernon thinks he,
and the rest of society, is stuck in some sort of rut of our approach to living and in need of a renewal or thawing of both
mind and heart. Just as it is difficult for people to shake their depressive
moods during the empty, dull, unimaginative, and static winter, Vernon argues
that people have been struggling to enlighten themselves to their place in the
world and approach life with bright eyes and an open mind.
The artist claims that society as
a whole has been settling for a meaningless life rather than actively working
to ask questions, contemplate, find purpose and really live. Evidence for the
problem in this behavior is revealed in the track titled “Creature Fear” of the
album where Vernon blatantly states, “So many foreign worlds//So relatively
fucked.” This single phrase is a major turning point of the song. The melody of
the song abruptly shifts from a calming, lullaby-like melody sung by one
passive voice to big, busy, drum instrumentation with loud, overpowering, and haunting
backup vocals. The musical switch happens so suddenly and unexpected that it mimics
the sensation of a friend playing a practical joke by creeping up behind you
unnoticed and screaming right in your ear in hopes of making you jump or waking you up. The
contrast in music helps to emphasize a sense of urgency in Justin Vernon’s warning
and advice to changing the way we view life.
With a less alarming tone, in
“Lump Sum,” Vernon gives his personal testimony that further demonstrates the
need for turning to nature in order to reflect and determine our intent and
role in society. The artist describes how he feels that something is missing in
his life and how nothing he does is ever enough, when he sings, “My mile could
not//Pump the plumb.” This song is especially important because it demonstrates
the inevitable moment when everything begins to fall apart in Vernon’s life due
to being idle and allowing his disorientation, distraction, and disappointment to
build up. The line, “All at once//Rushing from the sub-pump,” reintroduces the
water symbol from “Flume.” In this track however, the water is no longer
innocent, calm, and beautiful; it is overflowing, overarching and overwhelming.
But then Vernon continues with the song to reveal positivity in his message
when he advises, “Color the era//Film it, it’s historical.” “Color the era”
relates to breaking out of the white, wintery environment in order to paint life
how we want it and go out and experience the world for ourselves. With just
three words, the phrase “Color the era” sums up Bon Iver’s argument and forms a
perfect anthem for neo-Romanticism. The new view of the world that
neo-Romantics like Justin Vernon advocate for is all about using nature to
renew our imagination, knowledge, and understanding so that we may discover
fulfillment and purpose in life, as well as better ourselves and society as a
whole.
At the end of “Lump Sum,” Bon Iver uncovers
more positivity when he sings, “Balance we won’t know//We will see when it gets
warm.” This lyric mentions the most hopeful part of the current state of
society being trapped in a winter snowstorm: it is going to come to an end. In
this very last line, Vernon’s voice no longer has the cavernous quality to it.
His vocals have expanded to hold new weight with both depth and substance backed
by a hasty guitar rhythm, showing the artist is ready to look ahead to what
will come in the future with this driven attitude of life.
There is more evidence of healing
and hope in the track “Blindsided,” where the singer notices his “feet melt the
snow.” Bon Iver’s focus on winter, seasons, and elements of nature in general,
all transient and impermanent components of life, shows how our perspectives
are also temporary. In other words, Justin Vernon argues that if we invest
ourselves in using nature as a channel by which to ponder and reason, it is
possible to remove ourselves from the funk of feeling like we do not have direction
in life or a place in the world. Throughout the track there are intentional,
fluctuating noises intertwined with the consistent bass drum and distinguished guitar,
and these crackles, snaps, and inconsistencies weaving in and out of the sound
also produce the sentiment that nothing, not our mood, habits, perception,
identity, has to last forever. Through the neo-Romantic ideas in For Emma, Forever Ago, Bon Iver urges us
to seek out nature and seclusion to reflect and reconsider our will and drive
in the way we live life.
In the iTunes Bonus track, “Wisconsin,”
Vernon associates nature with being spiritual, holy or a piece of God’s work, which
could be a way to justify his action of turning to nature as a guide for life.
Vernon begs, Oh God don't leave me here//I will freeze till the end,” in a whispering
voice as if he is speaking under his breath. The notes of a single guitar are
muffled like the instrument is underwater, creating echoing sounds that add to
the solemn mood of the track. Early Romanticism was greatly affected by and
grounded in pantheism, a belief that nature and God are one and the same. This
ideology implies that nature is alive, which lends itself to Romantics turning
to nature for understanding and direction in finding their role in society
(Riasanovsky 72). Although Justin Vernon may not address nature and God as
equivalent beings in these lyrics; he does refer to the harsh winter weather as
an element that is in God’s control, making him inclined to investigate nature
as a means by which to learn about the world and discover a pathway leading to self-realization.
The last two songs of the album
are “Skinny Love” and “The Wolves (Act I and II).” I chose not to go into
detail on “Skinny Love” because it is Bon Iver’s most popular song with its sweeping guitar melody and recognizable chorus, (in fact it is the
only song of the entire album that has a concrete chorus.) “The Wolves (Act I
and II)” on the other hand, does not receive enough credit in the industry for
its beautiful, intricate sound. It is by far the busiest song of the album
musically, with a large presence of percussion instruments and an overlapping
of Vernon’s intense voice tracks. In addition, it has a section that features dramatic,
thundering firework sounds that are too powerful not to be experienced
first-hand.
For Emma, Forever Ago is a monumental piece of work. It not only is Bon
Iver’s debut album, but it also laid the stones to create the band altogether.
However, the music of this album is most significant in the way that Justin Vernon makes Romanticism relevant in contemporary society through his method for
creating the songs as well as his argument. This Bon Iver album suggests that diving into
nature as a form of meditation and reflection is effective to developing a
distinct awareness of ourselves. By contemplating nature, we are able to
connect with ourselves and focus on the course we want our life to follow, the
role we desire to hold in the world and the ways in which we can live life to
the fullest. Thus, the goal of this neo-Romantic view that Bon Iver presents does more than just promote a realization of our perspective of the world, it serves as a
call to action for all of us.
Bibliography
Bon Iver. For Emma, Forever Ago. Jagjaguwar, 2008.
CD.
Harmatz, Morton
G., et al. "Seasonal Variation Of Depression And Other Moods." Journal Of
Biological Rhythms 15.4 (2000): 344.Academic Search Complete. Web. 18 Nov. 2015.
Biological Rhythms 15.4 (2000): 344.Academic Search Complete. Web. 18 Nov. 2015.
Kravitt, Edward
F. "Romanticism Today." Musical Quarterly 76.1
(1992): 93. Academic Search
Complete. Web. 18 Nov. 2015.
Complete. Web. 18 Nov. 2015.
Riasanovsky,
Nicholas Valentine. The Emergence Of Romanticism. New York: Oxford University
Press, 1992. eBook Collection (EBSCOhost). Web. 9 Nov. 2015.
Press, 1992. eBook Collection (EBSCOhost). Web. 9 Nov. 2015.
"Songs in
the Dead of Winter." Perf. Justin Vernon. By Angela Kim. Weekend
America. Prod. Michael Raphael. Dir. Rob Byers. American Public Media.
St. Paul, Minnesota, 26 Jan. 2008. American Public Media. Web. 17 Nov.
2015.
America. Prod. Michael Raphael. Dir. Rob Byers. American Public Media.
St. Paul, Minnesota, 26 Jan. 2008. American Public Media. Web. 17 Nov.
2015.
Thoreau, Henry
David. Walden. Boston: Ticknor and Fields, 1854. Print.
Vernon, Justin.
"Justin Vernon of Bon Iver." Interview by Steven Hyden. A.V.
Club. Ed. Josh Modell. Onion, 21 Feb. 2008. Web. 16 Nov. 2015.
Club. Ed. Josh Modell. Onion, 21 Feb. 2008. Web. 16 Nov. 2015.